Sunday, October 27, 2024

Situational Awareness: Dock tragedy is latest chapter in Gullah Geechee community's long struggle. October 2024

Based on incident command system (ICS) structure.  This investigation falls under the span-of-control\jurisdiction of the County, and State of Georgia.
 
State of Georgia and County COULD REQUEST federal assistance from FBI and possibly NTSB or other (NIST) if requested.
 
For research purposed check the following:
 
1.     Surfside building collapse.  Miami, Florida.  2021.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surfside_condominium_collapse
 
2.     Hyatt Regency Walkway Collapse.  Kansas City, Missouri. 1981.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyatt_Regency_walkway_collapse
 
BEMA International
 
                    (NOTE:  Use link to view additional photos, and news coverage videos of ferry dock collapse)

Dock tragedy is latest chapter in Gullah Geechee community’s long struggle

 
By Ray Sanchez, CNN
CNN  —  
 
For the young daughters of Michael and Kimberly Wood, it was their first time at the annual festival celebrating the culture of the Gullah Geechee community on Georgia’s remote Sapelo Island, the birthplace of their maternal grandmother and other descendants of enslaved Africans. 
 
After a day of storytelling, poetry, religious dance and hope-filled spirituals a week ago Saturday, the Woods, other family members and dozens of festival goers waited on a floating dock and adjoining gangway for the scenic ferry ride to the mainland across marshy Doboy Sound. 
 
A loud cracking sound and a sudden shifting of the gangway were the only warning before the relatively new dockside aluminum walkway plunged into the water about 60 miles south of Savannah. The collapse killed seven people, injured several others and gave his two girls what Michael Wood said was their first glimpse of the Gullah Geechee community’s longtime heartache and resilience. 
 
“It’s that fight to survive,” said Wood, a quality assurance engineer who slid down the collapsed gangway, snatched his 74-year-old mother out of the water and handed her to a stranger on the dock. 
 
Wood said he unsuccessfully attempted to reach his 8-year-old daughter Hailey, who was eventually rescued by the boyfriend of a relative as she clung to part of the dock. His wife Kimberly, clinging to their 2-year-old daughter Riley and using a book bag as a flotation device, drifted away in the strong current before another stranger pulled them safely to shore. 
 
The October 19 tragedy is the latest chapter in the struggles of one of the last surviving Gullah Geechee communities in the Georgia Sea Islands. These descendants of Africans who were enslaved on coastal plantations in the Southeast have fought to preserve their ways of life amid what they describe as a long-standing policy of neglect by state and county officials.
 
“The call that the community has to its preservation is strong and runs deep, even risking their lives to save a life,” said Joyce White, a professor and interim director of the Gullah Geechee Cultural Heritage Center at Georgia Southern University. “The risk of life, or death in this instance, is for future survival.” 
 
Four women and three men, all of them older than 70, were killed in the collapse, which the head of the Georgia Department of Natural Resources said appears to have been caused by a “catastrophic failure of the gangway.” An engineering and design firm will conduct an independent investigation in the cause, the DNR said Friday. 
 
The victims were identified as Jacqueline Crews Carter, 75; Cynthia Gibbs, 74; William Johnson Jr., 73; Carlotta McIntosh, 93; Isaiah Thomas, 79; Queen Welch, 76; and Charles L. Houston, 77. They had traveled to the festival from Jacksonville, Florida, Atlanta and Darien, Georgia. 
 
Gangway inspected in 2022 after a ‘loud noise’ 
 
Those who died were among 700 visitors to the island for the annual Cultural Day celebration, which residents said used to attract as many as 2,000 people. Only 29 original descendants remain in the small hamlet known as Hogg Hummock or Hog Hammock, where their enslaved ancestors settled after being forcibly brought there in 1802. The state now owns most of the island. 
 
As festival goers waited to board a ferry returning to the mainland, the gangway came down. At least 20 people plunged into the Duplin River, officials said. There were as many as 40 people on the walkway at the time. 
 
The ferry dock was rebuilt in 2021 after a group of Gullah Geechee residents reached multimillion-dollar settlement with the state over what they claimed in a 2019 lawsuit were soaring property taxes and inferior treatment compared to the residents on the mainland. In 2015 federal civil rights claims, residents said they were paying high property taxes and receiving inadequate services including “water, emergency medical, fire, road maintenance, trash, and accessible ferry services to members of the community.”
 
The lawsuit against the state was settled in 2020 and the case against the county was settled two years later. The state settlement included the construction of the dock and “new aluminum gangways” as well as improved ferry service.
 
“There should be very, very little maintenance to an aluminum gangway like that,” DNR Commissioner Walter Rabon told reporters last Sunday, adding there were “almost daily” visual inspections of the structure.
 
The gangway passed four safety inspections since 2022, DNR said in a statement on Thursday. A subcontractor inspected the structure in May 2022, one day after the agency was “made aware of a loud noise that had been heard by a group on the gangway,” according to the statement. 
 
The May 2022 inspection and a follow-up later that year in December both found “no structural concerns with the gangway,” said the agency, which owns and runs the docks and ferries. Two additional inspections were conducted after recent hurricanes Helene and Milton and “no concerns” were identified, the statement said. 
 
The cause of the collapse is also being looked at by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation. Civil rights attorney Ben Crump – who is representing relatives of some victims – as well as a number of island residents have called for a federal probe. 
 
‘See where their grandmother grew up’ 

A week ago Saturday, Michael and Kimberly Wood, their two daughters, his mother Susie, and several other family members arrived on Sapelo from their homes throughout the state. The barrier island, about 7 miles off the coast of Georgia, is accessible only by boat or ferry.………………..
 
 
 
                    (NOTE:  Use link to view additional photos, and news coverage videos of ferry dock collapse)
ATLANTA (AP) — Georgia's attorney general brought in an engineering firm to conduct an independent investigation into a fatal dock collapse on Georgia's Sapelo Island during a celebration for the historic Gullah-Geechee nation founded by Black descendants of slaves.

Georgia's Department of Natural Resources, which operates the dock, and the Georgia Bureau of Investigation have already launched a state investigation into last weekend's incident. The state probe will continue as the firm, Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates conducts its own.

Seven people, all of them over 70, died after the aluminum gangway collapsed Saturday. Officials say around 40 people were standing on the dock when it snapped and about 20 plunged into the water, many of them sucked into heavy currents as they struggled for air. Eight were taken to the hospital, and at least six were critically injured.

 Two of the victims are still hospitalized as of Thursday, authorities said.

The state investigation could take a long time as the agencies interview witnesses and collect other evidence, including an inspection of the gangway at a “secure facility,” Walter Rabon, the Commissioner of Georgia’s Department of Natural Resources, said Tuesday, according to the Atlanta-Journal Constitution.

Rabon said the gangway was inspected by Georgia-based Crescent Equipment Co. less than a year ago and by the Department of Natural Resources after the recent hurricanes Helene and Milton.

The department oversees the dock's operations on the island, which is only reachable by boat and has no medical facilities. Seven hundred people were visiting Hogg Hummock on Saturday for the Gullah-Geechee people’s annual Cultural Day festival celebrating the community’s history. That day, the island buzzed with activity despite ongoing gentrification and tax hikes. Many Gullah-Geechee members have left the island for places with more opportunities and infrastructure.

Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who is representing relatives of three of the dead, said Tuesday that he doesn't trust the state to investigate the collapse. He called for the Department of Justice to investigate.

The 80-foot (24-meter) gangway should have been able to carry 320 people, according to the Georgia Department of Natural Resources. The dock was rebuilt in 2021 after residents sued Georgia officials over federal accessibility standards for people with disabilities on ferries and docks.

Hogg Hummock residents also argued in the 2021 lawsuit that McIntosh County didn’t provide enough emergency resources on the island. In a settlement with the community, McIntosh agreed to improve emergency services in part by building a helicopter landing pad. Residents say the launching pad has yet to be built. A helicopter evacuating people after the collapse instead landed in an overgrown field.

Members of the Gullah-Geechee community on and off Sapelo Island are still in mourning. Residents in Jacksonville, Florida, gathered for a prayer vigil to support grieving families Thursday at a local African Methodist Episcopal church with local pastors and politicians. Churchgoers honored those who died, who some now refer to as the “Sapelo Seven.”

 


 

Food Insecurity\Disasters\Higher Costs. Opinion: Disaster relief needed to help ag producers October 2024

         “Many producers have been waiting for assistance with natural disasters since 2022”
 
This is a reality.  Many farm workers, farmers, and ranchers are still waiting on financial relief from crisis\disasters (floods, wildfires, crop losses, etc.) since over 2022.  In some States there may even be no relief since 2019.  Small farmers are the most affected, and the alternative to multinational AG producers.
 
Once attending a 2023 Zoom session on farm workers, farmers, and ranchers it was stated that those groups were seeking relief since 2019.  One of the attendees mentioned that they noticed a look on my face of astonishment and basically disgust.
 
Farm workers, farmers, and ranchers are caught between three worlds of disaster relief:  (1). State\County programs, (2). USDA, and (3). DHS\FEMA. 

If all disasters initially start as LOCAL before federal intervention and assistance there are system failures in all three areas starting from local processes & procedures to address the threats, vulnerabilities, and risks for the local communities that the States and Counties play a major role. 

System patching, and redesigning the current systems is not the answer.  A new effective and efficient system may be the answer.  A starting point is open and full-inclusion for entire community.  The community of the public, farm workers, farmers, and ranchers have a voice.
 
Charles D. Sharp
Chair\CEO
BEMA International
(Black Emergency Managers Association International)
 Washington, D.C.
 
Opinion: Disaster relief needed to help ag producers

10/25/24 11:44 AM By Rep. David Valadao
 
The state of California is the fifth largest supplier of food in the world and accounts for 12.5% of the nation's agricultural production. However, recent natural disasters and extreme weather have put California’s farmers' ability to grow food and the security of our nation’s food supply at risk.

 

After years of extreme drought that cost California’s agriculture industry over $1 billion per year, atmospheric rivers and a lack of water storage infrastructure led to severe flooding throughout California’s Central Valley last year. Farmers went from fallowing land due to an unreliable water supply to dealing with thousands of acres of farmland under water.

 

It seems those who provide food for the nation can’t seem to catch a break.

 

While impacts on California’s agriculture industry are top of mind for me, farmers and producers across the entire United States have experienced significant agricultural losses due to floods, hurricanes, droughts, tornadoes, wildfires, and weather-related pest damages over the last few years. According to the American Farm Bureau Federation, severe weather and major disasters caused over $21 billion in crop losses just in 2023 alone. The states with the largest losses due to severe weather include Texas, Kansas, Florida, and California.

 

Natural disasters have severely affected crop and livestock production and continue to jeopardize our nation’s food security, as well as the economic stability of our rural communities.

 

 

 

 

We must act to provide much-needed assistance for farmers, ranchers, and rural communities impacted by natural disasters. I introduced the Agriculture Disaster Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act to provide the U.S. Department of Agriculture with an additional $14 billion to assist producers impacted by natural disaster losses in 2023.

 

In a perfect world, this kind of ad hoc assistance wouldn’t be necessary. Unfortunately, there are gaps in existing risk management programs at the USDA that necessitate additional support. Take dairy as an example.
 
During the flooding in the Central Valley in 2023, dairy producers incurred significant costs from property damage, feed losses, and transportation costs from moving livestock. When this happened, the industry quickly realized there were limited options for them to be reimbursed for these costs.

 

In a similar situation in Puerto Rico in 2017, then-Agriculture Secretary Sonny Purdue used Commodity Credit Corporation emergency assistance funds to help dairy producers. Unfortunately, Ag Secretary Tom Vilsack has not utilized his full authority within the CCC to do the same for producers impacted by the 2023 disasters. I’ve asked the secretary directly why dairy farmers who need help are getting left behind, and I introduced legislation so that there’s no question that the Secretary has the authority to use these funds.

 

The Agriculture Disaster Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act aims to make existing disaster programs more accessible for the dairy industry. The bill includes a $1.5 billion carveout for livestock losses and provides expanded assistance to livestock producers, including relocation of livestock, feed crop losses, and shelter-in-place procedures.

 

Right now, Congress is working on reauthorizing a new farm bill to improve and strengthen some of these disaster programs. But the timing of a new five-year authorization of the farm bill is uncertain, and our producers deserve timely access to relief. 

 

Many producers have been waiting for assistance with natural disasters since 2022. While we work on a new farm bill that includes additional crop insurance mechanisms, those tools will not be accessible for producers soon enough. Providing immediate assistance in the meantime is critical.

 

America’s farmers are resilient, but sometimes nature changes course, and producers are dealt another unpredictable set of circumstances. We must ensure our farmers are equipped to deal with these circumstances to secure the safety of our nation’s food supply.

 

Rep. David G. Valadao is a lifelong dairy farmer and represents California’s 22nd District. He is a senior member of the House Appropriations Committee and serves on the Subcommittee on Agriculture, Rural Development, and Food and Drug Administration.

RECOMMENDED READING LIST

Search This Blog

ARCHIVE List 2011 - Present